Price as Focal Point: Prediction Markets, Conditional Reflexivity, and the Politics of Common Knowledge
Price as Focal Point: Prediction Markets, Conditional Reflexivity, and the Politics of Common Knowledge
Authors: Maksym Nechepurenko Date: 2026-04-27 Paper ID: openalex:2604.24147
Summary
This paper challenges the view of prediction markets as solely forecasting devices, arguing they often serve as powerful coordination mechanisms that shape political behavior. By analyzing transaction-level data from the 2024 U.S. presidential election, the author introduces the Signal Credibility Index (SCI) to evaluate the conditions under which price signals gain behavioral traction. The results demonstrate that highly visible markets can significantly influence elite coordination even when their predictive accuracy is low, suggesting that social authority and epistemic robustness are distinct, often decoupled, features of these platforms.
Key Contributions
- Introduces the Signal Credibility Index (SCI) to quantify the behavioral influence of prediction market signals.
- Demonstrates a systematic decoupling of social authority from epistemic robustness in 2024 U.S. election prediction markets.
- Develops a framework to distinguish between market moves that function as forecasting tools versus coordination mechanisms.
Open Questions & Future Work
Key Concepts
- signal-credibility-index: A metric combining variance ratios, trader two-sidedness, and concentration to evaluate the potential for prediction market signals to drive real-world behavioral coordination.
Archivist Review
I approved the Signal Credibility Index as it provides a distinct, quantitative framework for evaluating the behavioral influence of market signals, which is highly relevant to the study of reflexivity in time-series forecasting. The open question regarding causal identification in reflexive markets was approved for its foundational importance in distinguishing between forecasting and coordination effects. I rejected the SCI weighting optimization question as it is a routine empirical task that does not constitute a fundamental, unresolved bottleneck.
Approved Concepts
- Signal Credibility Index: It provides a novel, microstructure-grounded metric for evaluating the real-world behavioral impact of market signals beyond simple price accuracy, specifically in reflexive market systems.
Approved Open Questions
- Causal Identification in Reflexivity: Without robust causal identification, it remains impossible to empirically verify the extent to which prediction markets are driving outcomes as opposed to merely reflecting or misinterpreting reality.
Rejected Candidates
- [open_question] Optimizing Signal Credibility Index (
sci-component-weighting-optimization) - low_impact: Weighting optimization is a standard empirical exercise that is often too specific to the implementation of a single index and lacks the theoretical depth of the reflexivity identification question.
Links
Metadata & Links
- url
- https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.24147
- paper_id
- 2604.24147
- paper_source
- openalex
- domain
- nlp
- tags
-
- architectures
-
- datasets
-
- concept_slugs
- signal-credibility-index
- dataset_slugs
-
- skill
- TimeSeriesSkill
- created_at
- 2026-04-30T06:03:39Z