Empirical Confirmation of the Environmental-Dominance Inequality A direct decomposition of Var(ln {ho}eff ) across four levels of aggregation
Empirical Confirmation of the Environmental-Dominance Inequality A direct decomposition of Var(ln \r{ho}eff ) across four levels of aggregation
Authors: Kristian Sestak Date: 2026-05-12 Paper ID: openalex:2605.12037
Summary
This paper provides an empirical verification of the environmental-dominance inequality, which asserts that the variance of effective density significantly outweighs that of intrinsic capability. By analyzing three public datasets at four aggregation levels—ranging from global individual distributions to U.S. census tracts—the author quantifies the dominance ratio and investigates its temporal stability. The results show that while the global aggregate remains stable, internal composition shifts between 1990 and 2022 confirm patterns of international convergence and domestic divergence. The study also confirms the robustness of this inequality across diverse socioeconomic metrics such as income and mortality rates.
Key Contributions
- Provides empirical validation for the environmental-dominance inequality, demonstrating that effective density variance consistently dwarfs intrinsic capability variance (Var(ln ρ_eff) ≫ Var(ln k)).
- Quantifies the dominance ratio across four levels of aggregation, revealing a shift from between-country to within-country dispersion between 1990 and 2022.
- Demonstrates the robustness of the environmental-dominance effect across distinct socioeconomic indicators, including income, infant mortality, and incarceration.
Open Questions & Future Work
Key Concepts
- environmental-dominance-inequality: A statistical inequality asserting that the variance of effective density significantly exceeds the variance of intrinsic capability.
Archivist Review
I have approved the environmental-dominance inequality concept and the corresponding open question regarding causal identification. The datasets are critical, domain-specific resources and meet the approval threshold for usage in economic and socioeconomic modeling. Other candidates were not submitted.
Approved Concepts
- Environmental-Dominance Inequality: Establishes a quantitative framework for analyzing the relative contribution of structural versus intrinsic factors to socioeconomic outcome variance across diverse scales.
Approved Open Questions
- Causal Identification of Dominance: This is a fundamental methodological bottleneck for verifying the strength of the environmental-dominance inequality against capability-based explanations.
Datasets
Links
Metadata & Links
- url
- https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.12037
- paper_id
- 2605.12037
- paper_source
- openalex
- domain
- nlp
- tags
-
- architectures
-
- datasets
- Opportunity AtlasWorld Inequality Database
- concept_slugs
- environmental-dominance-inequality
- dataset_slugs
- opportunity-atlasworld-inequality-database
- skill
- TimeSeriesSkill
- created_at
- 2026-05-15T06:16:24Z