SciPaths: Forecasting Pathways to Scientific Discovery
SciPaths: Forecasting Pathways to Scientific Discovery
Authors: Eric Chamoun, Yizhou Chi, Yulong Chen, Rui Cao, Zifeng Ding, Michalis Korakakis, Andreas Vlachos Date: 2026-05-14 Paper ID: openalex:2605.14600
Summary
The paper introduces discovery pathway forecasting, a new evaluation task that challenges models to reason backward from a target scientific contribution to the specific enabling building blocks and prior-work dependencies that make it feasible. The authors contribute the SciPaths benchmark, which includes expert-annotated and silver-standard pathways from machine learning and NLP literature. Evaluation of frontier language models reveals significant limitations in recovering methodological dependencies, highlighting a critical gap in current scientific AI capabilities.
Key Contributions
- Introduces discovery pathway forecasting, a task focusing on identifying enabling scientific contributions and their grounding in prior work.
- Presents SciPaths, a benchmark consisting of 262 expert-annotated gold pathways and 2,444 silver pathways within the ML and NLP domains.
- Demonstrates that current frontier LLMs perform poorly on this task (0.189 F1), identifying methodological dependency recovery as a major bottleneck.
Open Questions & Future Work
Key Concepts
- discovery-pathway-forecasting: A forecasting task that identifies the necessary enabling contributions and prior-work dependencies required to realize a target scientific contribution.
Archivist Review
I approved the novel task of discovery pathway forecasting and the SciPaths dataset, as they provide a structured framework for evaluating backward causal reasoning in scientific AI. I also approved an open question regarding decomposition limitations, as it captures a critical bottleneck identified by the authors. Other candidates were rejected to maintain the vault’s high bar for novelty and impact.
Approved Concepts
- Discovery Pathway Forecasting: It defines a novel task that moves beyond simple citation prediction to focus on backward causal reasoning of scientific dependencies.
Approved Open Questions
- Scientific Pathway Decomposition Limitations: Improving decomposition accuracy is identified as a primary bottleneck for end-to-end scientific pathway recovery and automated scientific planning, as accurate grounding depends fundamentally on having correct enabling search targets.
Datasets
Links
Metadata & Links
- url
- https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.14600
- paper_id
- 2605.14600
- paper_source
- openalex
- domain
- nlp
- tags
-
- architectures
-
- datasets
- scipaths
- concept_slugs
- discovery-pathway-forecasting
- dataset_slugs
- scipaths
- skill
- TimeSeriesSkill
- created_at
- 2026-05-17T06:07:45Z